Our Locations

Tipton, IN Office

116 S. Main St.,
Suite B
Tipton, IN 46072

  • !765-675-4809
  • < 765-675-4837
Get Directions

Cicero, IN Office

30 South Peru Street
PO BOX 828
Cicero, IN 46034

  • !317-984-3300
  • < 317-984-3338
Get Directions

Brownsburg, IN Office

511 South Saratoga Drive
Brownsburg, IN 46112

  • !317-858-8090
  • < 317-984-3338
Get Directions

Welcome to Penwell Insurance – We are Focused on You™!

At Penwell Insurance, our main objective is not just to sell you insurance. Our goal is to provide you with unbeatable service to ensure that the unique insurance needs of you, your family, and your business are taken care of.  We have plenty of experience serving residents and businesses in Indiana and we are proud of our history here and have locations in Cicero, Tipton, and Brownsburg Indiana.

Our experienced agents personally take the time to get to know each of our clients. We will work one-on-one with you to determine your specific needs, so we can then recommend the most appropriate insurance solutions for you or your business. How could we find the right policies for you without knowing you, your family, or your business on a personal level?

Our numerous relationships with reputable insurance providers allow us to create customized insurance solutions that can protect many facets of your life and business. Whether you are looking for personal auto insurance, home insurance, life insurance, or you are a business owner searching to protect the future of your investment, we are the independent insurance agent that can help you.

We want to remove the stress and uncertainty you may feel when it comes to your insurance options, and provide you with the peace of mind that comes from knowing that we are completely focused on you. When you have a problem, we won’t just return your call. We will be there for you like family, and help you every step of the way.

Join the Penwell Insurance family

Learn more about how we can help protect your family or business investments by calling our office at ​877-351-5132 or filling out our online quote form.


Client Testimonials

You have been wonderful to work with and easy to access and quick to respond. Thank you so much for that. You don’t see that enough these days! I really appreciate it. ~Katherine

Katherine Testimonial