Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
- WSWilliam S., Cicero, Indiana
“I’m thankful for Penwell Insurance meeting all of our Insurance needs and claims in a professional and timely manner! Everyone on the team is very helpful and caring! Thanks again!”
- CHConley H., Cicero, Indiana
“I have had my insurance through Penwell Insurance for about 4-5 years now, and it has been great since day one. Everyone has been helpful and nice from the start!”
Ben M., Cicero, Indiana“Penwell Insurance does a great job with being proactive and advocating for our best insurance coverage needs at the right price. Unfortunately, we have had two claims the past year and they were extremely helpful in ensuring the process was simple for us.”
- Derek S., Cicero, Indiana
“I love penwell. They have taken care of me for 3 years. Prompt responses and easy to shop insurance. Best thing I ever did was put my insurance in their hands and forget about it. Thank you!!! Updating – still happy”
- JHJohn H., Cicero, Indiana
“Kara was very responsive and professional. She was able to save me money each month on my auto and home with better coverage.”
- RZRon Z., Cicero, Indiana
“I recently signed up for new insurance for my home, autos and umbrella. I considered policies with Penwell and three other agencies. The policies with Erie and the service with Penwell were superior to the other options. Kara was the most professional and responsive. She asked good questions and provided thorough and clear answers. When she didn’t know an answer, she quickly consulted with others in the office and got me a response. Given all the ridiculous price increases in the insurance industry, I was able to get very good policies from Penwell. I could have gotten comparable policy costs from another provider, but the vastly superior service from Kara made the difference.”
- FJFrank J., Cicero, Indiana
“Heather and Christy are professional yet personal. Great job on answering questions plus following up on my concerns and needs. Switching to them was seamless. We had a claim and no matter the time of day/night they were there as promised. Check them out!!”
- MRMaria R., Cicero, Indiana
“Penwell insurance in Cicero is great. They gave us great pricing on our home and auto insurance. I would recommend them to anyone. Customer service was excellent.”
- SHSkye H., Cicero, Indiana
“The Penwell team is wonderful and easy to work with. We are so happy we moved our coverage to Penwell.”
- DDDaryl D., Cicero, Indiana
“Their staff goes above and beyond with service and follow up!”
- Jen Z., Cicero, Indiana
“Excellent customer service! Quick claim processing!”
- Darren P., Carmel, IN
